Available Mon-Fri, 9am-6pm ET  |  Call 800-970-1964

800.970.1964   |   Contact Us   |   Client Portal

How to Appeal a Denied Medicare Claim

Picture of Sylvia Gordon

Sylvia Gordon

Receiving a denial for a Medicare claim can be both confusing and frustrating. However, it’s important to know that you have the right to appeal denied Medicare claims. By understanding the appeals process, you can challenge decisions and potentially secure the coverage you need.

Navigating Medicare can be complex, but you don’t have to do it alone. The Medicare Family is here to help you learn about Medicare and find the right coverage. With over 40 years of experience, they offer free, expert advice tailored to your needs. Schedule your free call today to access top plans in your area and receive lifetime support.

Understanding Medicare Claim Denials

A Medicare denial happens when Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage (Part C), or Medicare Part D (which covers prescription drugs) decides not to pay for a healthcare service, item, or medication. This can be surprising and leave you wondering why it happened.

Many reasons could lead to a Medicare denial. One reason could be that Medicare decided the service was not medically necessary. Sometimes, denials happen because the hospital stay was too long, you used an out-of-network provider (especially with Medicare Advantage), or your medication is not on the list for Part D.

Common Reasons for Medicare Claim Denials

One common reason for a denial is that the service you asked for was seen as not necessary for medical reasons. This means Medicare found that there was not enough proof from your medical records to support the service. For example, they may deny your stay in a skilled nursing facility if your health does not need that level of care.

Another reason could be going over the maximum number of days allowed for hospital services or care at other healthcare places. Medicare has limits on how long they will cover certain services. If you go beyond these limits, you may get a denial.

Also, using a doctor or provider not in your plan’s network, especially with Medicare Advantage plans, can cause a denial. Every Medicare Advantage plan has its own list of approved providers. If you seek care outside this list, it might not be paid for, or it could lead to higher costs for you. It’s important to know the limits of your plan’s network to avoid surprise denials. If your claim is denied, your Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) or Explanation of Benefits (EOB) will explain why it was rejected and which Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) managed your claim.

Your Rights When a Claim is Denied

Receiving a denial does not mean it’s over. You have rights to appeal, and many appeals succeed in getting coverage. If your first claim is turned down, read the denial letter carefully. It will tell you why it was denied and explain how to start the appeals process.

You can write a request for an appeal. In this request, mention what parts of the denial you do not agree with and include extra information to support your case. Talk to your doctor or healthcare provider to get supporting documents, like medical records or letters showing the need for treatment, to strengthen your appeal.

Keep in mind that deadlines for appeals are very important. If you miss a deadline, it can lower your chances of winning the appeal. If you think you might need more time to gather the right documents or go through the appeals process, you can ask for extra time due to a good reason.

The Medicare Appeals Process

The Medicare appeals process has several levels where you can present your case. If your appeal does not succeed at one level, you can usually take it to the next level of appeal.

The number of levels of appeal and the rules for each level might be a bit different depending on if you have Original Medicare or a Medicare Advantage plan. Still, the basic structure stays the same.

First Level Appeal: Redetermination by a Medicare Contractor

The first step to appeal is called a redetermination. This means that a different Medicare contractor will review your claim again. This contractor was not part of the first decision. To start this process, check your Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) or Explanation of Benefits (EOB). These documents will show you how to file for a redetermination.

You should see a special section on your MSN or EOB where you can fill out details about the services or items that were denied and that you are appealing. The notice will also tell you when you need to file your appeal. After you fill out the required sections and collect any needed documents, send your appeal to the address for your Medicare contractor.

The contractor will look at your claim anew. They will think about why it was denied before, the evidence you provided, and any other information they find. They usually have a specific time to review your appeal and give you a decision.

Second Level Appeal: Reconsideration by a Qualified Independent Contractor

If the redetermination does not succeed, you can go to the next step of the appeal. This step is called reconsideration. It means that a Qualified Independent Contractor (QIC) will review your case. QICs are separate organizations that do not work for Medicare. This means they will look at your appeal fairly.

Just like in the first appeal, you will receive a decision letter from the redetermination. This letter will explain how to ask for a reconsideration. Usually, this means you need to fill out a specific form or send a letter to the QIC that will handle your appeal.

It’s very important to say why you think the previous decision was wrong. You should also provide any new and strong evidence to support your case. The QIC will look closely at every part of your appeal. They will consider your reasons and the evidence you provide.

Preparing for Your Medicare Appeal

A strong appeal has a better chance of winning. Before you start, carefully read the appeal instructions on your MSN or denial letter. These instructions will show what to put in your appeal request and where to send it.

Also, make copies of all important documents, like medical records, bills, denial letters, and other proof before you send them out. Keep the originals for yourself, as you may need them later if your appeal goes to a higher level.

Gathering Necessary Documentation and Evidence

The success of your appeal depends on having strong documents that support your need for the denied service or item. First, gather all important medical records. This includes doctor’s notes, test results, treatment plans, and anything that shows why the service is needed.

If your appeal is about a certain diagnosis, make sure to include all records related to that diagnosis. This should cover specialist visits and treatment history. If you are dealing with denials for stays in nursing homes or rehab centers, collect documents that show why you need that level of care.

For appeals about prescription drug coverage under Part D, you should gather proof that explains the medical need for the drug. This can be a letter from your doctor explaining why that specific drug is important for your health and why other listed medications won’t work for you. Remember, the more complete and relevant your documents, the stronger your case will be.

  • Medical Records: Doctor’s notes, test results, hospital records
  • Bills and Receipts: Make sure these match the denied services.
  • Denial Letter: This letter shows why your claim was denied.
  • Supporting Evidence: This could be a letter from your doctor, medical articles supporting your case, and if needed, papers from your employer if your appeal is about your job.

Tips on Writing an Effective Appeal Letter

When you write your appeal letter, keep it clear, brief, and respectful. Start by giving your Medicare number, the denial date, and the service or item you want to challenge. Explain clearly why you think the denial is wrong. Use specific evidence from the documents you collected. Avoid emotional words or accusations; focus on the facts and build a strong argument.

Make sure your letter is easy to read, well-organized, and free of mistakes. If you are asking for more time because of special circumstances, explain the delay and include the necessary documents. If you need help, reach out to your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) for free help.

End your letter by repeating your request for the appeal and include your contact information. Keep a copy of the letter and all related documents for your records.

Conclusion

In summary, dealing with a denied Medicare claim can feel overwhelming, but remember, you have the right to fight back. By learning how to appeal denied Medicare claims, gathering the right documents, and following the steps carefully, you can increase your chances of getting the coverage you need.

Don’t let a denial stop you from getting the care you deserve. If you’re feeling unsure or need extra help, The Medicare Family is here for you. With over 40 years of experience, we offer free, expert advice to guide you through Medicare and help you find the best plan for your needs.

Ready to get started?

Schedule your FREE call with The Medicare Family today. You’ll get personalized advice and access to the top plans in your area.

Sylvia Gordon, aka Medicare Mama®, is an expert on all things Medicare and Social Security. She is the 2nd Generation here at The Medicare Family and has served on the advisory boards of major insurance companies like UnitedHealthcare®, Cigna, and Anthem. In her free time, she can be found taking care of her animals (dogs, goats, peacocks, chickens), and reading a good book. Learn More.
5-stars
5-Star Rated

“This was the best experience I’ve ever had dealing with Medicare information.” – Darrell P.

About Us

For 40 years, our family has been helping seniors understand their Medicare benefits and find the best plan for their unique situation – the best part? Our service is always 100% free to you!

Wouldn’t this be

Easier on video?

Reading about Medicare can be confusing…Thats why we took all the important parts and put them into an easy, free video. 

Get Our FREE Medicare & Social Security Cheat Sheet 

Download this FREE printable cheat sheet to get the information you need in one place. You’ll never worry about forgetting a number, date, or deadline again. UPDATED FOR 2025!

Popular Articles

Beginner's Guide to Medicare

Learn how Medicare works, when and how to sign up, and a breakdown of all the coverage options in this easy guide.

3 Common Medicare Mistakes

There are several severe penalties to make sure you avoid when dealing with Medicare. If you get them, they can stay with you for life.

Medicare Costs for 2025

The costs for Medicare change each year. In this article we break down the costs for Medicare premiums and co-pays.